Pac-12 goodbye: Picks for football ‘Mt. Rushmore’ at Arizona, other programs

To commemorate the occasion — and give readers something to ponder over the holiday week — the Hotline presents our Mt. Rushmore selections: The greatest players to grace the field for each Pac-12 school.

(Consider it a complementary piece to our picks for the greatest football players in conference history.)

• We selected four players and included the names of five more who were given consideration. In truth, we considered more than nine. For some schools — hello, USC — our initial list was more than 15 deep.

• Performance in the NFL was not part of the calculation.

• Nor did we consider players who competed before their schools joined the Pac-12. For example, Mike Haynes is one of the greatest cornerbacks who ever lived, but his Arizona State career came before the Sun Devils entered the conference.

• Kickers and punters were excluded.

• Not every Mt. Rushmore selection is a record-holder for his school. Statistics mattered, but so did subjective criteria like impact and legacy.

Players: DE Tedy Bruschi, RB Ka’Deem Carey, LB Ricky Hunley, NT Rob Waldrop

Also considered: S Chuck Cecil, CB Darryll Lewis, CB Chris McAlister, WR Dennis Northcutt, LB Scooby Wright

Comment: Arizona was a defensive juggernaut for many years under Tomey, and our selections reflect that existence. Cecil made the greatest play in school history, a 106-yard interception return against ASU, and is plenty worthy of Mt. Rushmore status. We mulled Rob Gronkowski’s inclusion, but his college production was limited.

Players: OG Randall McDaniel, QB Jake Plummer, DE Terrell Suggs, DT Will Sutton

Also considered: S David Fulcher, LB Vernon Maxwell, DE Derrick Rodgers, OT Juan Roque, LB Pat Tillman

Comment: Plummer and Suggs were obvious picks; the others were pondered at length. Tillman’s total legacy is monumental because of his military service and death. But his on-field performance in Tempe, while first-rate, didn’t quite match the four listed on Mt. Rushmore in our estimation.

Players: TE Tony Gonzalez, RB Jackie Jensen, QB Joe Kapp, RB Chuck Muncie

Also considered: DE Andre Carter, RB Marshawn Lynch, CB Deltha O’Neal, OG Les Richter, QB Joe Roth

Comment: That’s right: No Aaron Rodgers. Or Steve Bartkowski. Or DeSean Jackson. (The bar in Berkeley is higher than you might expect.) With regard to Rodgers specifically, he had one superb season, in 2004, after transferring from junior college and before turning pro. Our selections performed to that standard and had longer college careers.

Players: LB Jimmie Gilbert, LB Nate Landman, WR Paul Richardson, WR Lavish Shenault

Also considered: CB Chidobe Awuzie, RB Jarek Broussard, CB Travis Hunter, RB Phillip Lindsay, CB Isaiah Oliver

Comment: Not many options for CU due to the school’s limited time in the conference and the paucity of elite players, which was reflected in the lack of success. (The Buffaloes were bowl-eligible twice in 13 seasons.)

Players: RB LaMichael James, QB Marcus Mariota, WR Ahmad Rashad, CB Mel Renfro

Also considered: QB Joey Harrington, CB Alex Molden, DT Haloti Ngata, OL Penei Sewell, OL Gary Zimmerman

Comment: We viewed Mariota, Rashad and Renfro as clear picks for Mt. Rushmore and gave James a slight lean for the fourth spot. Cornerback Kenny Wheaton was considered as the author of the defining play in school history (his interception against Washington in 1994), as was Justin Herbert. We considered both Mike Bellotti and Chip Kelly for the coaching position.

Players: QB Terry Baker, WR Brandin Cooks, RB Steven Jackson, DT Stephen Paea

Also considered: WR Vern Burke, WR Mike Haas, QB Sean Mannion, CB Jordan Poyer, RB Jacquizz Rodgers

Comment: If you’re unfamiliar with Baker, know that he won the 1962 Heisman Trophy. Burke was a star in the early ’60s, as well. The other selections reflect OSU’s success over the past quarter century. We also considered quarterback Derek Anderson, tailback Ken Simonton and defensive lineman Inoke Brecterfield.

Players: QB Frankie Albert, QB John Elway, WR Ken Margerum, QB Jim Plunkett

Also considered: QB Andrew Luck, RB Christian McCaffrey, DE Bill McColl, FB Ernie Nevers, WR Troy Walters

Comment: Few schools can match the Cardinal’s star power across all positions and even fewer can match the Cardinal’s lineup of quarterbacks. We considered Bob Whitfield and Toby Gerhart, among others, along with John Ralston, Bill Walsh and David Shaw for the coaching position.

Players: QB Gary Beban, S Kenny Easley, RB Jackie Robinson, LB Jerry Robinson

Also considered: QB Troy Aikman, RB Freeman McNeil, LB Don Moomaw, OL Jonathan Ogden, WR JJ Stokes

Comment: A heavyweight lineup of players, for sure. Easley and Jerry Robinson were three-time consensus All-Americans, and Beban won the Heisman in 1967. While obviously better known for breaking baseball’s color barrier, Jackie Robinson’s best sport in college was, in fact, football.

Players: RB Marcus Allen, RB Reggie Bush, S Ronnie Lott, OT Anthony Munoz

Also considered: OG Bruce Matthews, WR Keyshawn Johnson, RB Charles White, LB Richard Wood, OT Ron Yary

Comment: An impossible task given USC’s incredible tradition. Several Heisman winners did not make the cut; nor did coach Pete Carroll, despite his decade-long dynasty. And we should mention our standards for inclusion, while modest, leave no room on Mt. Rushmore for anyone accused of double murder.

Players: CB Jaylon Johnson, DT Star Lotulelei, RB Zack Moss, QB Cam Rising

Also considered: DE Bradlee Anae, OL Isaac Asiata, DT Leki Fotu, LB Devin Lloyd, DE Nate Orchard

Comment: The Utes had an impressive list of candidates considering their short stay in the conference (13 seasons), with linemen accounting for a high percentage of the players under consideration. Whittingham was not only Utah’s best coaching candidate but the only coaching candidate as he prepares for Year 20.

Players: DE Steve Emtman, RB Hugh McElhenny, QB Michael Penix Jr., OL Rick Redman

Also considered: RB Napoleon Kaufman, OL Lincoln Kennedy, S Lawyer Milloy, QB Marques Tuiasosopo, WR Reggie Williams

Comment: Only one selection, Penix, played for the Huskies during the Pac-12 era. Most other names should be familiar to fans who have tracked the conference over decades, but perhaps not Redmond, a two-time consensus All-American. Warren Moon’s exploits and legacy were rooted more in his pro career than his time at UW.

Players: C Mel Hein, QB Ryan Leaf, RB Reuben Mayes, QB Jack Thompson

Also considered: QB Drew Bledsoe, RB Steve Broussard, DT Rien Long, DE DeWayne Patterson, S Lamont Thompson

Comment: No specialist made a stronger case for inclusion than WSU’s Jason Hanson, arguably the best placekicker in conference history. And we gave serious thought to the late Mike Leach as the Mt. Rushmore coach, but Price had a longer tenure in Pullman and took the Cougars to the Rose Bowl, twice.